Top 20 Best Pizzas of 2021

Best of CU Best of CU Top 20 Best Pizzas of 2021Photo by Lillian Dent for Columbus Underground.
Decrease Font Size Increase Font Size Text Size Print This Page

The last time we asked our readers about the best pizza in Columbus was in 2019, and we published The Top 25 Pizzas in Columbus and felt that it was a pretty solid and definitive list of both old school and new school pizza joints around the city. But a few years later, we’re in need of an update, so we asked again for reader votes, and the new list has arrived!

In first place, once again, is Harvest Pizzeria. After opening the original location in German Village in 2011, Harvest became a quick fan favorite for their wood-oven approach and commitment to unique and local/seasonal toppings. The original location has since closed and several others have relocated or shuttered along the way, but four locations remain strong in Clintonville, Bexley, Dublin and The Brewery District, serving up signature pies. The “Ohio Double Bacon” and “Spicy Yuma” are both go-to options for those looking to try out Harvest for the first time.

For more info, visit www.harvestpizzeria.com.

Top 20 Best Pizzas in Columbus:

  1. Harvest Pizzeria
  2. Paulie Gee’s
  3. Yellow Brick Pizza
  4. Donatos
  5. Hounddog’s Three Degree Pizza
  6. Adriatico’s
  7. Tommy’s Pizza
  8. Grandad’s
  9. Mikey’s Late Night Slice
  10. Wizard of Za
  11. Rubino’s
  12. Fibonaci’s
  13. Goremade
  14. Borgata
  15. Dewey’s
  16. Romeo’s
  17. Jet’s
  18. Terita’s
  19. Flyer’s
  20. Natalie’s Coal Fired Pizza

Note: Our “Best of 2021″ lists are published as the results of our annual Reader Survey Poll.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email


features categories

Subscribe below: