Our City Online


Top 10 Best Pizzas in Columbus

Walker Evans Walker Evans Top 10 Best Pizzas in ColumbusPhoto by Susan Post.
Decrease Font Size Increase Font Size Text Size Print This Page

Columbus is full of great pizza, and at the end of the day, it’s all about your personal preferences. So what is the best pizza in Columbus? Do you like thick or thin crust? Traditional or contemporary ingredients? A sit-down dining experiences or home delivery?

We surveyed over 1,000 residents and found that there’s a wide variety of preferences out there based on the diversity of our full Top 25 Pizzas in Columbus list, but the bulk of the survey takers voted for Harvest Pizzeria in first place.

A relative newcomer to the list, Harvest’s first location opened in German Village in 2011, offering a cozy dining experience on a quiet side-street in the brick-lined neighborhood. The success of the first location’s high-quality wood-fired pizzas allowed it to quickly expand to new sites in Clintonville, Dublin, Bexley, Grandview Heights and even the Over the Rhine neighborhood in Cincinnati.

The photo pictured at the top of this pizza is the “Spicy Yuma” specialty pizza from Harvest, a recommended experience for those who’ve not yet tried it. The pizza is topped with Chorizo, Jalapeño, Corn, Roasted Red Peppers, a Gouda/Havarti Blend of Cheese on a Chipotle-Spiked Tomato Sauce Base.

For more information, visit www.harvestpizzeria.com.

The Top 10 Best Pizzas in Columbus, Ohio:

10. Rotolo’s Pizza
Grandview – 1749 West Fifth Avenue
Style: Hand-tossed, square-cut.

9. Mikey’s Late Night Slice
Multiple Locations in Central Ohio
Style: New York style, pizza by the slice.

8. Paulie Gee’s
Short North – 1195 North High Street
Style: Wood-fired, triangle cut.

7. JT’s Pizza & Pub
North Side – 2390 Dublin Granville Road
Style: Thin-crust, square cut.

6. Borgata Pizza Cafe
North Side – 5701 Parkville Street / 2285 W. Dublin Granville Road
Style: Hand-tossed, triangle cut.

5. Tommy’s Pizza
Multiple Locations in Central Ohio
Style: Thin-crust, square cut.

4. Yellow Brick Pizza
Olde Towne East – 892 Oak Street / Victorian Village – 245 King Avenue
Style: Hand-tossed, wood-fired, triangle-cut.

3. Hounddog’s Pizza
Old North Columbus – 2657 North High Street
Style: Thick-crust, triangle-cut.

2. Adriatico’s
University District
Style: Thick-crust, square-baked, square-cut.

1. Harvest Pizzeria
Multiple Locations in Central Ohio
Style: Wood-fired, gourmet, triangle-cut.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email


dining categories


This year’s Urban Living Tour event has been postponed due to COVID-19, but will be returning later this summer!

CLICK HERE to sign up to be notified when tickets go on sale!