Our City Online


The 2012 Downtown Columbus Condo Wrap-Up

JoePeffer JoePeffer The 2012 Downtown Columbus Condo Wrap-Up
Decrease Font Size Increase Font Size Text Size Print This Page
  • Sumo

Would you believe that 165 condominiums sold in the 43215 Downtown Columbus zip code in 2012? It’s true. That’s about 30% more than the previous year, 30% more than 2010 and 40% more than the number of condos that sold in 2009 in and around Downtown Columbus.

At an average of $237,130 per condo, we’re talking about an increase in Downtown residential purchasing of nearly $12 million over the previous year. 43215 condos would include all of Downtown, the Southern Short North, some of the Northern Streets in German Village and the Brewery District, and of course, the Arena District.

Though some of these Downtown Columbus condos may not have ever been lived in, few were newly built. Also, there were no clear runaway pockets Downtown as these sales were nicely spread out, with many of the prior lackluster performing properties making a good showing.

Here are some of the highlights from last year’s condo sales in Downtown Columbus, in alphabetical order:

8 On the Square – 8 East Broad Street – Three units sold, a one, two and three bedroom unit — that’s right, for you naysayers out there who complain about there not being any three-bedroom condo units in Downtown Columbus. That model unit was on the 11th floor, with over 2,100 square feet plus two balconies. You might recall that this unit was once listed at just over a $1 million, but sold last year for $599,000 after over three years of availability.

Atrium Lofts – 106 North High Street – Four one-bedroom units and two two-bedroom units. This reinvigorated building saw only six sales last year but that’s a coup for a well-located building best known for its multistory light well. The one-bedroom units averaged $121,500 and the two bedroom units averaged $173,500.

The BuggyWorks – 448 West Nationwide Boulevard – It was a pretty good year for one of Columbus’ only true New York loft style condo communities. Buggyworks had nine sales in 2012: the four one-bedroom units that sold averaged 1,041 square feet and sold at an average of $209.72/sqft. The six two-bedroom units at Buggyworks sold for an average $217.27/sqft and had an average of 1,273 sqft. The largest unit sold in 2012 was 1,649 sqft and sold for $365,000. The taxes are only $1,002 per year and the monthly condo fee is a steep $500 per month. Sometime in 2016, the taxes for many of these will adjust to non-tax-abated levels. A 1,200 square foot short sale sold for $216,000 after originally selling for $279,000 back in 2006.

Burnham Square – 250 Daniel Burnham Square – Since they were built in 2006, Burnham Square condo units have done a remarkable job keeping their value. Seven units sold last year, five of them being two-bedroom units. Those five Burnham Square units sold for an average of $245.21 per sqft, though that’s slightly misleading as two of them were the extra large units at 2,200 and 2,400 square feet which sold for $495,000 and $625,000 respectively.

Carlyle’s Watch – 100 East Gay Street – Carlyle’s Watch, at the Downtown uber-corner of Third and Gay Streets continued the momentum of 2011 with seven sales averaging a brisk 77 days on market. The three one-bedroom units that sold averaged $147,167, 821 square feet and 36 days on market. The four two-bedroom units averaged $215,000, 1,258 square feet and 106 days on market.

Cityview at 3rd – 78 East Chestnut – Lest they feel slighted, six units sold at Cityview on 3rd in 2012. I’ve never been a big fan of the project, though I appreciate the location. All one-bedroom two-bathroom condos, these averaged $148,500 per unit and a bargain $151.18 per sqft. This building has been through some tough times in recent years and these legitimate sales sure beat rentals if you ask the previous buyers.

The Dakota – 845 North High Street – Yep, still located within the 43215 zip code, the Dakota had five sales last year: two one-bedroom units at $176,000 and 126 days on market (though one was a short sale) and the two-bedroom units went for $250,000, $255,000 and $337,500, the later being about 200 square feet bigger and the former being ultra-motivated.

Exchange Urban Lofts – 110 North Third Street – Always a fan favorite, Exchange Urban Lofts just did ok last year. Four units sold with two of the three two-bedroom units having an identical 1,456 square feet and selling in under six weeks for an average of $257,700 (just over $175 per sqft). Will these units be a harder sell when tax abatements begin running out in 2014?

Harrison Park – Harrison West – One of the big winners last year, albeit they were due, was Harrison Park with 11 total sales. Many of these units have come down in price since being built in 2008 and buyers liked the low condo fees and minuscule taxes. The one-bedrooms units averaged almost 1,000 square feet and $170,000, and the two-bedroom units went for just under 1,200 square feet and just over $201,000.

Miranova – One Miranova Place – It was a breakout year for Miranova as the Queen of Columbus Condos, which had 11 sales, eight of them being two-bedroom units that averaged a mere 57 days on market and $190 per sqft. One interesting sale was a 2,440 square foot 21st floor unit listed at $640,000, which sold for $550,000 after a quick three days on the market.

Neighborhood Launch – Gay Street – 2012 was another solid year for Downtown’s newest condo development. Curb appeal and location will keep buyers coming back for more at Neighborhood Launch. Highlights include two one-bedroom units that sold in one day, another that took 16 days on the market, a three-bedroom unit in the contemporary block on North Fifth Street that went for $385,500, and an end unit with two bedrooms, 2.5 baths and nearly 2,000 square feet in the newest Gay Street block for $495,000. Curious what the condo fees would set you back on that? Only $169 per month… compare that to aforementioned Miranova unit at $1,488 per month. I guess it’s all about what you consider to be important amenities.

North Bank – 300 West Spring Street – Speaking of high-rise condo developments in Downtown Columbus, North Bank had four sales that were entered into the Columbus MLS. That’s important to note because many of the new sales are sold by the building’s sales team and not entered in the MLS database. These four sales (all resales) were all two-bedroom units that averaged $482,100 or about $268 per square foot. Great Location, great views, great amenities.

One Ninety Nine – 199 South Fifth Street – It was an overdue breakout year for this development that sold eight units in 2012. Known for their giant terraces, 199 sold two one-bedroom units, and the six two-bedroom units that sold went for an average of $211 per sqft or $275,150 for your average 1,297 square foot unit.

Terraces on Grant – 196 South Grant Avenue – Six two-bedroom units sold in Terraces last year. Built in 2006, these units had struggled to sell but like many other buildings in Downtown Columbus, Terraces saw a slight resurgence in popularity. These condos averaged 1,170 sqft and a sales price of around $164 per sqft, or about $186,000.

Victorian Gate – Victorian Village – Last but not least in terms of location, Victorian Gate continued to be popular with buyers looking to be in the middle of the happening Short North and Goodale Park area. Victorian Gate saw 12 condo sales in 2012. The seven one-bedroom units averaged $205 per sqft and a sales price of $161,000 for just over 785 square feet and a quick 57 days on market. The two-bedroom condos sold for $170 per sqft for just over 1,500 square feet of space and a sales price of $261,540 in only 100 days on average.

Waterford Tower also saw five sales, one of them a two-bedroom unit for $199,900. The bulk of the rest of 2012’s condo sales were sprinkled throughout Downtown Columbus, as well as the residential streets of the Short North and the Brewery District.

Joe Peffer is the Managing Partner of the Delicious Real Estate Group and Broker of Record at Re/Max Town Center. All information from Columbus Area MLS and deemed reliable.


metro categories

subscribe_email Get Columbus News Updates in Your Inbox!

Stay in the know! Enter your email address to subscribe to the latest news: