Our City Online

Cookie Cravings Bakery

Cookie Cravings Bakery Relaunching as Cravings Carryout Café

Ayana Wilson Ayana Wilson Cookie Cravings Bakery Relaunching as Cravings Carryout Café

When Cookie Cravings Bakery opened little over two years ago in the Italian Village, it was with the intention of making and serving fine baked goods and confections, like sugar cookies, shortbread, and everything in between. The bakery was started by Matt and Lindsey Tewanger and Matt’s Mother, Joan. The couple met while working at […]

2 Comments

Treat to Try: Pistachio Berry Sticky Bun at Cookie Cravings

Anne Evans Anne Evans Treat to Try: Pistachio Berry Sticky Bun at Cookie Cravings

Columbus Underground is celebrating Valentine’s Day a week early with Treat Week! We’re profiling all types of desserts, baked goods and other local sweets. I stopped in Cookie Cravings Bakery for their brunch last Saturday and it is very difficult to limit yourself to one item when there are so many lovelies to choose from. […]

No Comments

Treat to Try: Apple Brown Butter Strudel at Cookie Cravings

Anne Evans Anne Evans Treat to Try: Apple Brown Butter Strudel at Cookie Cravings

Cookie Cravings Bakery has been trying out some new items lately. Today, they have a Groundhog’s Day Brunch going on until 4pm. They’ve got several new items for this brunch, one of which is the Apple Brown Butter Strudel. I’ve covered several fruit filled pastries on this column, and I’m always ready to try another. […]

No Comments

Cookie Cravings Bakery now offering crepes

Anne Evans Anne Evans Cookie Cravings Bakery now offering crepes

The bakery in Italian Village you have come to love for cookies is giving you another reason to love them all over again. Monday, Cookie Cravings Bakery started selling savory and sweet crepes. “After making it through our first 6 months, we realized that we wanted to offer more to our customers,” says Lindsey Tewanger. […]

7 Comments

New Bakery Cookie Cravings Open in Italian Village

Anne Evans Anne Evans New Bakery Cookie Cravings Open in Italian Village

A new cookie shop has opened in Italian Village. Nestled at the southeast corner of Fourth Street and Third Ave, Cookie Cravings Bakery opened last month. Lindsey Tewanger and a close friend had been baking and decorating cookies for about a year for friends. When the orders kept coming, they became difficult to manage as […]

6 Comments

dining categories

Join us for the Beer & Pretzel Pairing Party on November 3rd featuring Combustion Brewing & Happy Little Treats!

CLICK HERE FOR TICKETS & INFO