ADVERTISEMENT

    Restaurant Review: Belly Burger

    Expectations were not high for Belly Burger. It seems like a quick-flip, a random burger shop set up pell-mell inside the shell of Oliver’s. A month after opening and half the shelving in the bar was still barren. 

    ADVERTISEMENT

    Then again, to be fair, Oliver’s old shelving behind the bar runs all the way up the walls. There’s no real compelling reason to store a bunch of bottles out of reach of bartender. That doesn’t make sense at all. Keeping the booze on lower shelves is surely a practical choice, if ever there was one. Perspective is helpful here. 

    Beyond the shelves, the walls of Belly Burger are spray-painted with a groovy 70s burger theme, with a retro soundtrack to match (think CCR or Rolling Stones). And when it comes to food, Belly Burger is set up with a super-streamlined menu that’s paired with order-at-the-counter service. 

    As it turns out, the burgers are not bad. At times, exemplary, even, and really good deals for Downtown. It’s always nice when expectations are exceeded.  

    The Single ($5) is a warm-up. It provides a modest, coarse-ground burger, a criss-cross of length-wise pickle slices, lettuce and tomato all seated in a soft split bun that is griddled curiously golden all the way through. There’s a dab of special sauce to pull it together – it’s reminiscent of McD’s take on Thousand Island. You can add other stuff, like ketchup, mustard, onions and bacon. The burger’s not big, but for what it is, it’s decent value at only five dollars. 

    Original Belly Burger – Single

    But if you go all in with the Triple with Cheese ($9.50), that’s where the magic starts. Good night, that is a satisfying burger. As the name suggests, you get three of those meaty patties, with crisped edges. They’re held together with American cheese, plus that same criss-cross of crisp pickles, lettuce, tomatoes and special sauce. Burgers and gluttony go together like bread n’ butter, so this mammoth monster scratches an itch that the mere single will never reach. 

    Original Belly Burger – Triple

    Then lightening strikes twice. The Cluck ($5.75) was good too. It’s real chicken. This fact was not immediately evident when the sandwich arrived because the crunchy-fried piece was somehow oddly circular to match the bun. But there is a distinct difference between chicken and parts, and this was really and truly intact poultry, battered with extra crispy crackling coating, seated on the golden bun with pickles. 

    The Cluck

    That’s pretty much it for the edibles: Burgers and Chicken Sandwiches. You can round it out with the house Salt & Pepper Fries ($2.25). While the pepper element wasn’t terribly evident, they are certainly seasoned fries, and solid companions to the sandwiches. 

    Salt & Pepper Fries

    In the beverage department, you can score all the typical drinkables you’d find at any bar, PLUS milkshakes and Cheerwine Slushees. The latter is built on a Southern classic, a soda called Cheerwine ($4). According to the internet, the red beverage is named for its cherry flavor, and the cheeriness it imparts. A slushie format just accentuates those features (add booze, and the cheeriness expands exponentially). You can doctor up the milkshakes with alcohol, too.  

    Cheerwine Slushee

    The street address for Belly Burger is 26 N. High St. but the entrance itself is in Lynn Alley.

    For more information, visit belly-burger.com.

    All photos by Susan Post

    ADVERTISEMENT

    Subscribe

    More to Explore:

    The Confluence Cast: Downtown with Michael Brown

    We're exploring the evolution of downtown with Michael Brown, who has been a cornerstone in the city's development planning and worked both in and outside city government to cheer on its growth. Columbus Underground editor Walker Evans and Mike delve into the city's challenges and triumphs, the synergy between projects, the balance between iconic and neighborhood-level public art investments, and the concerted efforts to address systemic issues like homelessness and affordable housing. Through anecdotes and insights, they highlight Columbus's young, creative energy and the dynamic urban policies that continue to drive its growth.

    14 Easter Brunches in Columbus

    No holiday calls for a big, fancy brunch quite...

    Main Street Delaware Launches “Just Next Door” Brand to Enhance Downtown Identity

    In response to the voices of downtown businesses and the community, Main Street Delaware recently unveiled a new identity brand for Downtown Delaware – "Just Next Door." 
    Miriam Bowers Abbott
    Miriam Bowers Abbotthttps://columbusunderground.com
    Miriam Bowers Abbott is a freelancer contributor to Columbus Underground who reviews restaurants, writes food-centric featurettes and occasionally pens other community journalism pieces.
    ADVERTISEMENT