Our City Online

Messageboard - General Columbus Discussion

NOTE: You are viewing an archived version of the Columbus Underground forums/messageboard. As of 05/22/16 they have been closed to new comments and replies, but will remain accessible for archived searches and reference. For more information CLICK HERE

My Favorite Pub: O'Reilly's. What's Yours?

Home Forums General Columbus Discussion My Favorite Pub: O’Reilly’s. What’s Yours?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 98 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #79293
    crsimp01
    crsimp01
    Participant

    You can love it, hate it or just be indifferent towards it, but you can’t take away the fact that O’Reilly’s Pub in Clintonville has all makings of that place where everybody knows your name (and not because your face is plastered on a wanted poster).

    I have heard some of the issues a few people have with it – it is small, too loud at times, it can get crowded now and then, etc. – but come on…really…it is a local pub. It isn’t a chain restaurant and it doesn’t promote itself as a family place (which it isn’t). O’Reilly’s, at 2822 North High Street, is a place you go to grab a beer, a quick (outstanding) dinner, watch a game and converse about your past week’s misadventures with close friends. Sure it still resembles a service station gone bad from the outside, but inside you will find a close knit staff who considers all patrons like acquaintances from the past.

    The Irish themed joint has menu of what may be considered typical pub food, but folks it is better than that. They have munchies (what they call their appetizers) that include, sweet potato fries, wings, nachos and fried mac & cheese. What they really hang their hat on, or should do more promotion on in my opinion, are the burgers. The Bacon BBQ Burger is the one I typically go after (a 1/2 pound of heaven on a bun), but other favorites include the Jerk Burger and the Pepper Burger. Those in our group of Thursday O’Reilly’s barflies tend to prefer the Jerk Burger, or the “The Tom Burger” as it is sometimes referred to (I’ll let you try and figure out the reasoning behind it as it is an experience to behold).

    Though we can’t really prove it, we believe we can tell when Johnny is working his magic in the kitchen. That’s not to say that the rest of the kitchen doesn’t know what they are doing, but on some nights those burgers literally melt in your mouth. And more often than not that’s when you get a glimpse of Johnny kicking butt and taking names with his pub kitchen prowess.

    Even if you aren’t a burger person you can pick and choose from a variety of chicken, fish, turkey, roast beef, ham and grilled bologna sandwiches. Or, if subs are your delicacy, you can dig into things such the Italian, Club, White Pizza, Veggie or Johnny’s sub. The latter is formerly known as the “Gonzo” and for good reason. It consists of salami, ham, pepperoni, turkey, bacon, onion, green peppers, banana peppers, tomato, lettuce, cheddar and provolone cheese with your choice of Italian dressing or pizza sauce. It will set you back about $9.00, but it is huge and will make you work to finish it.

    You will find that there are daily specials that include homemade favorites like meat loaf and mashed potatoes, corned beef and cabbage and others. It is a filler of a meal at a decent price. Better yet, the specials change weekly. When St. Patrick’s Day rolls around you get a specials menu loaded with Irish favorites. These, too, are worth your time.

    Our group of oddballs and misfits (Christine, Allison, Doug, James, Evan, Joy, Julie, Jay, Craig) make it a weekly ritual to meet there on Thursday nights. This is highlighted by the fact that Ann Marie, bar tender extraordinaire, is the vixen dishing out the beer and spirits. If you are a returning customer, she usually knows exactly what you want…unless you just want a change of pace. She makes it as if you are a regular, even if you are a first timer. If you really want some fun, make sure you play “Ball and Biscuit” by The White Stripes when you swing by the jukebox. Ann Marie will appreciate it.

    Thursday’s are typically jam-packed, but to tell you the truth I don’t think I would want to hangout at a place that was always dead and empty. And being a relatively small place, you’ll have a crowd now than then. You can still enjoy those warm days of summer by sipping your favorite brew on the patio. For those inside people the eclectic atmosphere is something that will keep you mesmerized. Just when you think the place doesn’t fit you or you feel out of place, you find something (or someone) that will remind you that deep down we are all the same.

    It not may be much to look at, but if you think about a neighborhood joint that thrives on being there for you whenever you feel the need…it serves its purpose. I don’t think anyone would complain, or at least, have a legitimate gripe. The same can be said for other Clintonville pubs like Patrick J’s, the India-Oak Grill or Crest Tavern.

    You can find out for yourself what O’Reilly’s is all about by swinging by there any day of the week. Better yet, crash the Christmas party Monday, December 21st at 6 p.m. or just be there on December 17th and sample the awesomeness that is beer bread!

    This is my pub, my watering hole, my home away from home. It isn’t perfect and is not the ideal place for everyone, but I wouldn’t want it to be. It is an odd place full of characters that will make you laugh and stare in wonderment.

    It is O’Reilly’s and I wouldn’t want it any other way.

    Okay I’ll get off my soapbox, but what about you? What’s your favorite place…and why?

    #327032

    Elizabeth Lessner
    Participant

    Great review. O’Reilly’s has a most wonderful bar staff too. Love, love, love Tom, AnnMarie, Alisa, Johnny, Petey, Rick, Marty & crew.

    #327033

    Ann Marie for mayor of Clintonville!

    #327034

    gk
    Member

    M. Close to home.

    #327035
    crsimp01
    crsimp01
    Participant

    Comments appreciated folks! Thanks! ;)

    #327036

    CMH Gourmand
    Participant

    You are now on probation for sharing Clintonville’s greatest secret – shame on you – now it will be more crowded.

    AnnMarie is the best bartender in Columbus – her ability to remember names and what you typically order is incredible.

    How about picking a bar that can use some business and start a cult following for them instead.

    #327037

    patient_zero
    Participant

    Everybody should have their Cheers, a place they enjoy and feel at home. Your love for O’Reilly’s is evident. The one place I’ve enjoyed over the years is Mac’s Cafe in the Short North. This is a place where I feel comfortable by myself at the bar, or with friends at a table or booth. Sometimes we grab some beers and play pool in the back.

    Besides that comfort level, I enjoy most of the menu and beer offerings as well. A decent pub will usually have great burgers, fries, club sandwiches and soup which they do, but being a Scottish Pub you’ll also find Shepherd’s Pie, Forfar Birdie, and Scotch Eggs. They’ve tweaked their menu a few years ago and offer great lunch specials and nightly specials with discounts up to 50% off. There’s usually something unique on tap, and you can buy Boddington’s and McEwans’ in the can. I’ve brought friends, family and coworkers there for as long as I can remember and everyone’s enjoyed it.

    Although I miss Bones the bartender, Joey has been there for some time and he’s always been good to me. It’s easy to start up a conversation with any of the staff or the folks sitting around you at the bar.

    They could really use a website, though!

    As it starts to get cold, I like the warm interior of Claddagh Irish Pub[/url] on Front Street. I think this is a great place to celebrate with friends over some drinks, as it’s spacious with a lot of areas to feel comfortable. The warm dark interior reminds me of some far off place in Ireland, which just enhances the experience.

    Their food has always been very good, especially the Guinness battered cod. Wash that down with a few pints and I’m a content guy. The service there has always been warm and friendly.

    #327038

    Charlie
    Member

    Press Grill – My favorite neighborhood bar. I feel comfortable any day of the week there. They do a great job. Good food, good beers, good juke box, friendly service.

    #327039
    Jimmy Mak
    Jimmy Mak
    Participant

    patient_zero wrote >>
    Everybody should have their Cheers, a place they enjoy and feel at home. Your love for O’Reilly’s is evident. The one place I’ve enjoyed over the years is Mac’s Cafe in the Short North. This is a place where I feel comfortable by myself at the bar, or with friends at a table or booth. Sometimes we grab some beers and play pool in the back.

    +1. Joey is a great bartender and always welcoming.

    I also have fond memories of O’Reilly’s, though I haven’t been for a long time. I used to go there for karaoke in the 90’s. Might have to head back for a beer …

    #327040

    catnfiddle
    Participant

    I’ve only been to O’Reilly’s once but found it wonderfully welcoming.

    #327041

    DavidF
    Participant

    jmak wrote >>

    patient_zero wrote >>
    Everybody should have their Cheers, a place they enjoy and feel at home. Your love for O’Reilly’s is evident. The one place I’ve enjoyed over the years is Mac’s Cafe in the Short North. This is a place where I feel comfortable by myself at the bar, or with friends at a table or booth. Sometimes we grab some beers and play pool in the back.

    +1. Joey is a great bartender and always welcoming.
    I also have fond memories of O’Reilly’s, though I haven’t been for a long time. I used to go there for karaoke in the 90’s. Might have to head back for a beer …

    If you want to meet me for karaoke, your beer is on me. I’m a karaoke nut.

    I’ve always had a soft spot for Hey Hey. I don’t really know why, just something about that place that speaks to me.

    #327042

    patient_zero
    Participant

    @ DavidF – Otani[/url] has karaoke on Fridays as well, but I go there for the sushi.

    #327043

    Lakee911
    Participant

    Someone here recommended O’Reilly’s to me a few weeks ago. I’ve been back many times since. It’s a great place!

    #327044

    blammo
    Participant

    I’m hopelessly devoted to the Treehouse. I’ve had the best and worst nights of my life in that place, and it’s probably the only bar I’ve ever hung out in extensively. If you lower your expectations accordingly, you will never be disappointed.

    #327045
    Jimmy Mak
    Jimmy Mak
    Participant

    DavidF wrote >>
    If you want to meet me for karaoke, your beer is on me. I’m a karaoke nut.
    I’ve always had a soft spot for Hey Hey. I don’t really know why, just something about that place that speaks to me.

    I just might take you up on that! But I go to observe, there’s a reason they don’t let me on the other side of the stage at Shadowbox. :)

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 98 total)

The forum ‘General Columbus Discussion’ is closed to new topics and replies.

Subscribe below: