Our City Online

Messageboard - Dining

NOTE: You are viewing an archived version of the Columbus Underground forums/messageboard. As of 05/22/16 they have been closed to new comments and replies, but will remain accessible for archived searches and reference. For more information CLICK HERE

Best sandwiches in town

Home Forums General Columbus Discussion Dining Best sandwiches in town

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 71 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #83762

    jungaroo
    Member

    I searched the message board and saw bits and pieces of threads that touched on this topic. Let’s settle it once and for all (or not). What are the best sandwiches in town?

    My favorites:

    – corned beef at Danny’s Deli

    – ahogada torta at Cuco’s

    – muffuletta at Creole Kitchen

    – cubano at Plantain Cafe

    – pot roast at Tip Top (I also dig the Monte Cristo, though it’s not quite traditional)

    – Reuben at Spinelli’s Deli

    #406705

    Kahiki
    Member

    The White Anchovies sandwich at Cafe Corner.

    #406706

    FADulous
    Member

    Danny’s is one of the best delis in the city (if not the best). A close second: Milo’s. Great desserts too.

    #406707
    Walker Evans
    Walker Evans
    Keymaster

    Gonna repeat my faves from this thread:

    Best unusual sandwiches

    Will have to think about if I have some other new faves to add… ;)

    ————

    Turkey Pesto on Focaccia at Cafe Brioso
    Oven roasted turkey tossed with Brioso’s own house basil pesto, mayo and red onion.

    Jalapeño Joe at Spinelli’s Deli
    Turkey, Jalapeño Bacon, Pepperjack Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato and Chipotle Mayo on a Cheddar Roll.

    Swiss Melt at Cafe Corner
    Artichoke hearts, crumbled bacon, sauteed onions, amish swiss cheese, dijon horseradish sauce, grilled on sourdough bread.

    Spice of Life (#8) at Brown Bag Deli
    Roast beef, turkey, corned beef, scallion, cream cheese, tomato, onion and Batampte mustard on a French roll.

    Ohio Style Monte Cristo at Tip Top Kitchen & Cocktails
    Shaved turkey, ham, swiss cheese and honey mustard between battered and grilled slices of texas toast.

    #406708
    jarsloth
    jarsloth
    Participant

    Walker wrote >>
    Gonna repeat my faves from this thread:
    https://www.columbusunderground.com/forums/topic/best-unusual-sandwiches
    Will have to think about if I have some other new faves to add… ;)
    ————
    Turkey Pesto on Focaccia at Cafe Brioso
    Oven roasted turkey tossed with Brioso’s own house basil pesto, mayo and red onion.
    Jalapeño Joe at Spinelli’s Deli
    Turkey, Jalapeño Bacon, Pepperjack Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato and Chipotle Mayo on a Cheddar Roll.
    Swiss Melt at Cafe Corner
    Artichoke hearts, crumbled bacon, sauteed onions, amish swiss cheese, dijon horseradish sauce, grilled on sourdough bread.
    Spice of Life (#8) at Brown Bag Deli
    Roast beef, turkey, corned beef, scallion, cream cheese, tomato, onion and Batampte mustard on a French roll.
    Ohio Style Monte Cristo at Tip Top Kitchen & Cocktails
    Shaved turkey, ham, swiss cheese and honey mustard between battered and grilled slices of texas toast.

    I love the Spice of Life… which reminds me I haven’t been to Brown Bag in quite some time.

    #406709
    Lauren Wilson
    Lauren Wilson
    Participant

    Banh Mi from MiLi Cafe
    egg and white anchovy from Cafe Corner
    Veggie Melt from Surly
    Mother Mohawk from Old Mohawk
    Corned beef from Danny’s (which I haven’t had in at least 3 years!)
    and another big thumbs up for ahogada torta at Cuco’s…although if you forget the leftovers in your car, that smell takes FOREVER to come out

    #406710

    honavery
    Member

    My favorites off the top of my head are the Turkey Pesto from Brioso and the Mohawk Stroller from Brown Bag. Oh, and also the Grilled Buttermilk Black Pepper Chicken from Skillet.

    #406711
    Snarf
    Snarf
    Participant

    The sliders at Old Bag of Nails are the chronic. Side of bbq and jalapenos, mmm mmm!

    #406712
    Lauren Wilson
    Lauren Wilson
    Participant

    Which reminds me that the sliders at Little Palace are uhmazing.

    #406713
    Porky
    Porky
    Participant

    The folks over @ Si Senior are throwing down some mean Cuban inspired sammiches.
    My current addictions from them are the Turkey and Jalapeno, nice smoked turkey with the perfect amount of heat and spice.
    And their meatloaf with Charizzo (sp) is the slam.
    Other favs are Jalapeno Joe from Spinelli’s, the Tuna sandwhich from Barrio, the Chicken Parmasean from that Pizza place in the North Market, name escapes me now.

    #406714

    cyclist II
    Participant

    bbq chicken sub at Lac Viet. $4

    Big Italian with fired egg and siracha at Captain Cream Cheese

    White Castle fish w/cheese

    #406715

    saralinds
    Member

    The only sandwich I regularly crave is the #3 Wheezie’s Cheezie from Brown Bag Deli. Yum, honeycup mustard : )

    #406716
    vestanpance
    vestanpance
    Participant

    osulew wrote >>
    ahogada torta at Cuco’s…

    Cuco’s yes… but you have the sandwich all wrong. Cubana is where it’s at.

    #406717

    honavery
    Member

    Sort of related, the Spinelli’s downtown is open to the public as of today!

    #406718

    Nitsud Regnifloh
    Participant

    Si Senor on Long Street. hands down.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 71 total)

The forum ‘Dining’ is closed to new topics and replies.