Archives for "Restaurant Reviews"

Columbus Underground’s restaurant reviews are written by Morgan Kelley, our official Restaurant & Food Critic. We hope to share with you the good, bad and the honest about our local dining scene in an unbiased fashion. Review recommendations can be emailed to food@columbusunderground.com.

Review: Commonwealth Sandwich Bar

Review: Commonwealth Sandwich Bar

10 Morgan Kelley / January 4, 2012 11:30 am

The Commonwealth Sandwich Bar opened last spring, and I’ve been planning on trying it out ever since, but have failed to do so until now. Reviews have been mostly positive, and after it made the Columbus Underground list of “Best… [Read More]

Review: Graffiti Burger

Review: Graffiti Burger

12 Morgan Kelley / December 21, 2011 1:00 pm

Just two and a half years ago, the Great Burger Wars of Columbus began. Five Guys Burgers & Fries had just begun opening stores in the Central Ohio market when a local challenger rose up to take them head on…. [Read More]

Review: Romeo’s Pizza

Review: Romeo’s Pizza

2 Morgan Kelley / December 14, 2011 1:30 pm

Romeo’s Pizza opened their newest location in Clintonville just a week ago, which marks the eighth installment of the business in Central Ohio. This Medina-based chain has quickly grown over the past decade from one shop in suburban Cleveland to… [Read More]

Review: Akai Hana

Review: Akai Hana

0 Morgan Kelley / November 30, 2011 8:00 am

Akai Hana is an authentic Japanese restaurant which celebrated 25 years in business in 2011. Their menu includes a mix of Japanese-style and Western-style sushi, noodle bowls, several Korean entrees, yakitori and more. The restaurant decor feels like a throwback… [Read More]

Review: The Original Max & Erma’s

Review: The Original Max & Erma’s

0 Morgan Kelley / November 23, 2011 8:00 am

When is a chain restaurant not a chain restaurant? When its got local roots. Or at least that’s what I tell myself when visiting restaurants like The Original Max & Erma’s location in German Village. Originally opened in 1958 by… [Read More]

Review: Rancho Alegre

Review: Rancho Alegre

3 Morgan Kelley / November 16, 2011 5:30 pm

There was much bemoaning the loss of the Tee Jaye’s Country Place restaurant at the corner of Dublin Road & Grandview Avenue when it closed several years ago. Eventually, the sorrow was replaced with rejoicing when a Tex-Mex restaurant opened… [Read More]

Review: Dan’s Drive-In

Review: Dan’s Drive-In

2 Morgan Kelley / November 9, 2011 3:45 pm

Ah, the classic American Drive-In. All of the nostalgia of the 1950s, with a menu that has no need for updates in the past half century. Dan’s Drive-In meets us halfway there, with a solid diner menu and plenty of… [Read More]

Review: zpizza

Review: zpizza

2 Morgan Kelley / October 26, 2011 1:00 pm

zpizza (with an intentional lowercase z) is a franchise based in Laguna Beach, that serves California-style pizza in locations all around the US, including two in Columbus — one in the Short North, one in Clintonville. Knowing that the Clintonville… [Read More]

Review: Calvin’s Corner

Review: Calvin’s Corner

2 Morgan Kelley / October 19, 2011 8:00 am

Good southern food is hard to come by in Columbus. We’ve got a handful of upscale restaurants that go all out on specific menu items (the Shrimp & Grits at G. Michael’s immediately comes to mind), but when it comes… [Read More]

Review: Milo’s Deli & Cafe

Review: Milo’s Deli & Cafe

4 Morgan Kelley / October 12, 2011 8:00 am

If Franklinton is considered a hidden gem, then Milo’s Deli & Cafe a gem within a gem. Hidden in plain sight on West Broad Street, this unassuming shop offers little in the way of street presence or curb appeal, but… [Read More]

Review: Cazuela’s Grill

Review: Cazuela’s Grill

10 Morgan Kelley / October 5, 2011 4:45 pm

The University District and The Old North Columbus neighborhoods are teeming with dining options. Unfortunately, aside from a few stellar standouts like Alana’s and Blue Mile, most everything else caters exclusively to the college student demographic. Which isn’t always a… [Read More]

Review: Michael O’Toole’s Restaurant & Bar

Review: Michael O’Toole’s Restaurant & Bar

3 Morgan Kelley / September 21, 2011 4:15 pm

Looks can be deceiving. That was the theme of my recent visit to Michael O’Toole’s Restaurant and Bar. The large sign outside the restaurant claims that they were established in 1898, but in reality they only opened last year. The… [Read More]

Review: DK Diner

Review: DK Diner

4 Morgan Kelley / September 14, 2011 8:00 am

Tucked away on a residential street near Grandview Heights you’ll find the DK Diner. After re-reading some older reviews from Breakfast with Nick and CMH Gourmand, I was excited to check it out and see what the buzz was all… [Read More]

Review: Hubert’s Polish Kitchen at The North Market

Review: Hubert’s Polish Kitchen at The North Market

5 Morgan Kelley / September 7, 2011 8:00 am

This North Market vendor originally opened as Hania’s Olde World Cuisine, later changing the name to Hubert’s Polish Kitchen. Don’t let the switch confuse you though… Hubert Wilamowski has been at the helm since day one and continues to serve… [Read More]

Review: Basil Restaurant

Review: Basil Restaurant

11 Morgan Kelley / August 31, 2011 10:45 am

Basil is a part of the “Fourth Avenue Restaurant Row” in the Short North, which includes The Surly Girl Saloon, Barrel 44, and eventually a new Jimmy V’s Grill & Pub. No one has ever referred to those restaurants with… [Read More]