Our City Online


Review: Basil Restaurant

 Morgan Kelley Review: Basil Restaurant
Decrease Font Size Increase Font Size Text Size Print This Page

Basil is a part of the “Fourth Avenue Restaurant Row” in the Short North, which includes The Surly Girl Saloon, Barrel 44, and eventually a new Jimmy V’s Grill & Pub. No one has ever referred to those restaurants with that label, but I am. These four restaurants sit practically on top of each other, and each offers a wildly different environment, atmosphere and menu.

Basil is a Thai concept which opened two years ago by Rhome Ruanphae. According to their website, it was modeled after a similar restaurant concept in Chicago operated by his mother. The menu is composed of primarily traditional Thai dishes, with a handful of Chinese staples.

On the flip side, the decor is retro/modern/industrial with exposed brick walls, dark wood tones, and extremely dim (almost too dim) lighting. Despite the contrast between the classic dishes and the modern decor, the restaurant feels intimate and comfortable and makes for a great venue whether you’re bar hopping or grabbing a quick lunch. They have also been hosting monthly Quality dance parties which are on Gallery Hop Saturday and prove to be a great time.

Upon my most recent visit to Basil, I started off with an order of the Egg Rolls ($4.50 for two) which are quite a bit different than your standard pork-and-cabbage Chinese take-out variety. These fried spring roll wrappers are filled with a mixture of ground chicken, thin vermicelli noodles, carrots and sprouts. I found that the ingredient changes make for a nice departure from the norm. They may even be my favorite egg rolls in the city! The sauce is a pretty standard sweet & sour dip, but it gets the job done.

The Cucumber Salad ($5) is a clean and simple veggie medley of cucumber slices, red onions and carrot bits, finished with a vinaigrette-based dressing and topped with cilantro and jalapeno. It’s a light and refreshing salad.

One of my favorite dishes at Basil is their Sweet Potato Fries ($4.50). Traditionally, sweet potatoes are sliced and deep fried just like normal potatoes, but the twist at Basil is to first batter them in tempura prior to frying. This cooking variation gives the yams a softer, almost mushy texture while the tempura adds a half-chewy half-crisp outer shell. Occasionally, I’ve found them to be a little inconsistent in their doneness, but still tasty regardless. They’re served with a sweet and spicy Thai dipping sauce that works quite well.

Basil serves several types of soup, including Tom Ka ($5 cup, $9 bowl). This coconut-based chicken soup contains mushrooms, green onions, cilantro, lemon grass, citrus leaves, lime juice and galingale. Like several of the dishes at Basil, this soup suffers from a slight imbalance of ingredients. The lime juice overpowered the other spices and flavors, making it hard to taste anything beyond the sourness of the citrus. I also thought that the citrus leaves could have been strained out before serving, as they had hardened to the point of disrupting the creaminess and fluidity of the rest of the soup without contributing additional flavor by being there post-cooking. With a few minor adjustments, this could be a much better dish.

The Pad See Ewe ($9.50) is another dish that I wanted to like more if it weren’t for the overpowering nature of a single ingredient. This dish came with chicken by default (also available in a vegetarian tofu version) in addition to sen yai wide rice noodles, egg and Chinese broccoli and a brown sauce… but really all I could taste was the broccoli, which was almost like a brussels sprouts flavor to this dish. Not that it was a bad thing, as I do like brussels sprouts, but when I can hardly make out anything else, it doesn’t quite feel right. The broccoli gave the dish a bit of a mushy texture.

Hands down, the Crispy Noodle Kee Mow ($9.75) is one of the best entrees at Basil. The same type of flat rice noodles are used as with the Pad See Ewe, but first they’re fried to a crisp before being stir-fried with chicken, red bell peppers, tomatoes, onions and sprouts. The fried noodles give this dish a much more interesting texture and the soy-based sauce adds familiarity without being overpowering. Loved it. This will probably be my new staple order from Basil (this plus the aforementioned egg rolls!).

The Basil Chicken ($9.50) is one of several dishes on the menu with the namesake title. This rice dish is served with bits of ground chicken, basil, onion, red bell pepper, garlic and chili. For the most part, it’s a fairly decent stir-fry dish, but it still felt unbalanced. There was no mention of fennel on the menu, but my serving was most certainly doused with a heavy dose of fennel flavoring. I couldn’t help but wonder if the dish shouldn’t be called Fennel Chicken instead.

Overall, there’s both hits and misses to be found at Basil, and it may take some trial and error on the part of the guest to find your favorite dishes on their fairly expansive menu. Upon my next visit, you know I’ll be sticking to the egg rolls and Crispy Kee Mow and will go home extremely happy. But the same might not be said for someone who orders one of the several dishes that wind up with a heavy-handed dose of extra lime or broccoli or fennel.

I can’t help but wonder if there is an issue with continuity in the kitchen at Basil. Either recipes aren’t being followed too closely, or different kitchen staffers take liberty to cook menu items a bit differently on different days. Either way, I’ve found the food at Basil to be an adventure worthy of taking if you don’t mind some slight inconsistency. And if you don’t want to break the bank, there are lunch and happy hour specials that allow you to try a variety of items with lower prices and smaller portions. They currently have a Happy Hour menu from 4-7pm that allows you to try an assortment of dishes at $3.95 each (Special Menu, discount coupons cannot be used for it).

Basil is located at 1124 N High Street in the Short North. Hours, menus and more information can be found online at www.basilshortnorth.com.

Print Friendly


  • tolemac5050

    Faveroo featuring Basil today, $20 for $10. 

  • drew

    “I also thought that the citrus leaves could have been strained out before serving, as they had hardened to the point of disrupting the creaminess and fluidity of the rest of the soup without contributing additional flavor by being there post-cooking.”

    The ‘citrus leaves’ are almost certainly lemongrass. They’re an expected component of any tom kha.

    “There was no mention of fennel on the menu, but my serving was most certainly doused with a heavy dose of fennel flavoring. I couldn’t help but wonder if the dish shouldn’t be called Fennel Chicken instead.”

    That’s not fennel, it’s Thai basil (or the similar Thai holy basil). Both have a fairly strong anise/licorice flavor, not unlike fennel. It should be expected that basil chicken/pork/etc. (aka pad gra pow), will have serious quantities of Thai basil.

    That said, I do generally agree with the thrust of the review – there are far better Thai restaurants in town than Basil.

  • DavidF

    I agree with Drew, both about the ingredient issues in the review, and the fact that there are better Thai places in town.

    That said, I have enjoyed Basil when I’ve been there and I think it’s a great addition to the Short North. The Basil martini was excellent the last time I was there.

  • theonlynikki

    Their menu looks so amazing and these photos are making me drool.  I’ve been dying to try their food. 

    I went in at lunch one day not too long after tyhe opened and aside from 1 other couple we were the only people in the place.  And it still took 15 minutes just to get a drink order, while the waitress just stood around chatting with the cook.  Sadly we had to leave because we only have an hour lunch break and we;d already spent half of it waiting for water.

    I’d love to go back, but I sure hope to get better service next time.

  • I recently rediscovered this place.  I highly recommend the tamarind curry.  When I saw the faveroo for it today that’s all I could think about.

  • Lindsay

    tolemac5050 is right! $10 gets you $20 towards food and drink from Basil today at Faveroo.com. Happy Dining!

  • howatzer

    Basil is “pricey”? Seriously? Have you been anywhere else in the SN?

  • First, I’d mention that I am glad to see Basil getting some press as its one of my favorite restaurants in Columbus and I am always surprised by the number of people who haven’t been.  So that said I might be a bit biased, but I thought the review was a bit off.  Just speaking technically I am not sure how accurate this review is on some issues for example the reporting on the menu. For one the review says that the pad se ewe comes with “chicken by default (also available in a vegetarian tofu version)”, the menu actually says for all the noodle dishes: “Choice of meat includes, beef, pork, chicken, or tofu. Add $2.00 for shrimp or squid. Vegetarian preparation upon request.”   (Also gotta disagree on the flavor profile the reviewer describes, but hey its my favorite item on the menu so maybe we just differ.  I get it medium spicy, crispy noodles, with tofu if your interested) The reviewer also seems to like the crispy version of pad kee mow, but doesn’t mention that it is by default soft, and that both it and pad se ewe are available crispy for $1 extra (the crispy versions are amazing and well worth it).  I won’t harp more on the misunderstandings of Thai ingredients but think that took some of the review’s credibility away.  (oh and in my opinion Basil’s soups are amazing, very complex flavors,  especially tom yum.  Well worth eating around the lemon grass).

  • mrsgeedeck

    If I order cuisine and the broccoli tastes like brussel sprouts, we have an issue. And I like both broccoli and brussel sprouts, but the expectation in flavor is vastly different for me.

  • Lauren Wilson

    Well it is Chinese broccoli. And I’ve never had any Chinese broccoli that tastes like brussel sprouts, but it does taste a lot like asparagus. It definitely doesn’t taste like regular broccoli. I hope the reviewer didn’t expect it to. But I’d also assume an understanding that a basil dish at a Thai restaurant would include Thai basil…and a basic understanding of what Thai basil is.
    Also I had that pad see ew at Basil once. It was the only inedible meal I’ve had in recent memory in Columbus. I should probably go back and give something else a try, but it was so terribly bad I can’t bring myself to do it with Nida’s serving consistently amazing food a block away.

  • I’ve been to Basil maybe a dozen times, and have always enjoyed just about everything there. The panang chicken is a personal favorite and will probably continue to order it over and over again. I wish their happy hour had a couple of cocktails on the menu though. Last time I was there I only saw beer & wine.

    It also doubles as a fun dance party venue for Quality. ;) http://www.columbusunderground.com/forums/topic/quality-at-basil-gallery-hop/page/3

  • Snarf


dining categories