Otterbein College, soon to be renamed Otterbein University has a nice little thrift store near the park. Hours are Wednesday and Saturday, 12-5.
The Otterbein College Thrift Store, managed by the Westerville Women's Club, provides a place where the Otterbein and Westerville communities can practice reusing unwanted items. The thrift store has also a partnership with the Westerville Area Resource Ministry, a choice pantry, to allow clients to receive goods at further discounted prices. Items not sold in the thrift store are sent to mission churches in Southern Ohio. All proceeds from the thrift store are donated by the Westerville Women's Club to the College in the form of scholarships.

Women's Club Thrift Store Building #60 on campus
177 W.Park St 823-1444