Chris, based on your resources, my advice is to move the site to Wordpress and purchase a theme.
The process would cost you all at the most $150 bucks.
Woothemes is a place where you can purchase an affordable theme that can support the general content pages of the site. Additionally, if you are able to have a consistent publishing schedule Wordpress will make it easy if you do choose to blog.
As an organization, the number one thing you should be doing is building your email list. The site should make it dead simple for someone to give up their email address. Incentives (free reports, free tickets, private invite only events) help you increase the number of conversions to build that list.
I use a few services to manage my lists. I recommend Aweber, but I also use MailChimp and Campaign Monitor.
Aweber has great tutorials on their site to help you understand the basics of email marketing.
For any non-profit organization thinking about the web, the number one question I would be asking is - "What would Obama do?".
The Obama site is still the most innovative use of the web I've ever seen for a (non-profit) organization. They make it dead simple for you to connect with "what they believe" - "their story". They also make it dead simple for you to share that story and lastly, most importantly - they make it dead simple for you to give up your money and really not get anything in return. But, you feel like your getting something because you buy the story.
Non-profits aren't much different. You're constantly asking money for what's mostly intangible. You better get your story right. Good writing, images and video are in disposable to get that point across.
If I ran a non-profit's web efforts I would be dissecting Obama's digital efforts inside and out.




Launched in August 2010, TheMetropreneur.com is a local online resource devoted to small business development and entrepreneurship. Its aim is to tell the stories of Central Ohio's business community, foster regional economic development and assist entrepreneurs with its resource-heavy focus.