Bagels By Captain Cream Cheese - New in Short North « Columbus Underground Messageboard

Columbus Underground Messageboard » General Columbus Discussion » Dining

Bagels By Captain Cream Cheese - New in Short North

[247 posts] [69 contributors]

Topic Rating:

(Total Ratings: )
Rate this topic:

Started 2 years ago by crsimp01
Latest reply from L.I. to Buckeye

Tags:

« Previous 123…13 Next »

laChewla
Victorian Village, The Heart Of It All
Login to Send PM

SamuraiJack wrote >>
sounds delish... maybe I'll finally find something to compare with the old Beekman's Buckeye sandwich.. onion bagel, roast beef, smoked cheddar and mustard.. steamed to perfection.. ahh..

We're not steaming anything. However I did have a roast beef melt in mind. I really want Zach to make a bagel with fresh roasted garlic baked in.

My current favorite is the BIG ITALIAN. HUGE BAGEL with Peppadews baked in topped with garlic, italian herbs, red pepper flaked and aged provolone. HOLY DELICIOUSNESS. I tried one at home when Zach wasn't around and almost started crying.

Posted 2 years ago #
SusanB
Hungarian Village, Columbus' fastest growing Gayborhood!
Login to Send PM

Years ago in the late 80's-early 90's there was a bagel place in the Short North, just too far ahead of its time. They were great and also had non dairy spreads for the vegans. Mmmmm, now I want a bagel!

Posted 2 years ago #
avariell
Around Town
Login to Send PM

Bristol Bar wrote >>
It's north of downtown, south of OSU campus. From Gooddale to Smith Place (north to south) and from Olentangy River Road to 4th Street (west to east)

Hehe... I should have been clearer. I know where the SN is :) I meant where is this bagel place gonna be within the SN - but thanks for trying!
Can anyone give me an address? Or like what this bagel place is next to? As I have no idea what Mikey's Pizza Hut is. Thanks :)

Posted 2 years ago #
Snarf
Dystopia
Login to Send PM

Sounds neat. Hours seem a little odd, it's not breakfast bagels it's lunch and late lunch bagels?

Posted 2 years ago #
somertimeoh
Harrison West
Login to Send PM

avariell wrote >>

Bristol Bar wrote >>
It's north of downtown, south of OSU campus. From Gooddale to Smith Place (north to south) and from Olentangy River Road to 4th Street (west to east)

Hehe... I should have been clearer. I know where the SN is :) I meant where is this bagel place gonna be within the SN - but thanks for trying!
Can anyone give me an address? Or like what this bagel place is next to? As I have no idea what Mikey's Pizza Hut is. Thanks :)

Just south of Bodega.

Posted 2 years ago #
SamuraiJack
Hilliard
Login to Send PM

laChewla wrote >>

SamuraiJack wrote >>
sounds delish... maybe I'll finally find something to compare with the old Beekman's Buckeye sandwich.. onion bagel, roast beef, smoked cheddar and mustard.. steamed to perfection.. ahh..

We're not steaming anything. However I did have a roast beef melt in mind. I really want Zach to make a bagel with fresh roasted garlic baked in.
My current favorite is the BIG ITALIAN. HUGE BAGEL with Peppadews baked in topped with garlic, italian herbs, red pepper flaked and aged provolone. HOLY DELICIOUSNESS. I tried one at home when Zach wasn't around and almost started crying.

I could live with a roast beef melt on a garlic bagel... yummy.. should do bagels with pepperoni and cheese baked in.. *dies*

Posted 2 years ago #
laChewla
Victorian Village, The Heart Of It All
Login to Send PM

Another, sweeter combo I really want to try: Bagel with dried apricots baked in. Toast and top with cream cheese and honey.

Susan - We will hook up the vegans. We just can't call the place Captain Hummus.

Posted 2 years ago #
laurencaye
Italian Village / Short North
Login to Send PM

Just heard that Kickstart will be getting bagels, which is great (and makes me feel good for being one of the 1 million strong in support), but being that this is next door to my apartment, I am much more excited about this. Can't wait.

Posted 2 years ago #
VicVillage Guy

Login to Send PM

Does anyone remember when Burmuda Onion used to be in the Happy Greek location? I loved their bagel sandwiches. That place was great.

Posted 2 years ago #
Mercurius
First Avenue
Login to Send PM

I had a chance to try the bagels and they were super tasty and home made! Any idea of price yet? Are there going to sammies too or just bagels.

Here is a place I like down in Athens maybe to just get some ideas of toppings?
http://www.campusfood.com/restaurant.asp?restid=1334&campusid=247

Posted 2 years ago #
SJT

Login to Send PM

I won't eat here unless everything is $1 or less ;-) Ha.
I do remember the Bermuda Onion! Loved that place. Seriously though, glad to see someone bring more bagels to the SN& wish them success!

Posted 2 years ago #
placebohigh
The Short North
Login to Send PM

I'm incredibly excited about this place! I love Mikey's Late Night Slice and frequent it often and this is EXACTLY what the Short North is lacking. I'm super psyched and can't wait!

Posted 2 years ago #
kitty

Login to Send PM

@Mercurius World's Best closed 2 years ago, so sad :( I loved their bagels and the goo balls. Over sibs weekend they would make M&M cream cheese sounds gross, but it was pretty good.
Is there a chest hair free guarantee w this Captain's bagels? ;-)

Posted 2 years ago #
Mercurius
First Avenue
Login to Send PM

kitty wrote >>
@Mercurius World's Best closed 2 years ago, so sad :( I loved their bagels and the goo balls. Over sibs weekend they would make M&M cream cheese sounds gross, but it was pretty good.
Is there a chest hair free guarantee w this Captain's bagels? ;-)

This is my sad face.

Posted 2 years ago #
crsimp01
Columbus, Ohio
Login to Send PM

This just shows the power of social media in PR and Marketing. Your welcome! ;)
I'm only kidding..but I can't wait for the bagels either! When is the official open date...? Thanks!

Posted 2 years ago #
cyclist II
Short North & Peach District
Login to Send PM

Captain Cream Cheese calls on all able-bodied men to look across the Lord's expansive blue Sea and be content, for ye know that glorious bagels are on the horizon

Posted 2 years ago #
cyclist II
Short North & Peach District
Login to Send PM

Snarf wrote >>
Sounds neat. Hours seem a little odd, it's not breakfast bagels it's lunch and late lunch bagels?

They are more likely to be 8am-5pm. Don't know if I'll have a full selection ready to roll by 8am though. Small oven...

Posted 2 years ago #
michaelcoyote
!seabus
Login to Send PM

cyclist II wrote >>

Snarf wrote >>
Sounds neat. Hours seem a little odd, it's not breakfast bagels it's lunch and late lunch bagels?

They are more likely to be 8am-5pm. Don't know if I'll have a full selection ready to roll by 8am though. Small oven...

This is why bakers wake up at 4am

Posted 2 years ago #
Snarf
Dystopia
Login to Send PM

cyclist II wrote >>

Snarf wrote >>
Sounds neat. Hours seem a little odd, it's not breakfast bagels it's lunch and late lunch bagels?

They are more likely to be 8am-5pm. Don't know if I'll have a full selection ready to roll by 8am though. Small oven...

Cool...best of luck!

Posted 2 years ago #
Skinny_Buddha

Login to Send PM

Will there be any bagels with peaches or the word "peach" in the title?

Posted 2 years ago #