Columbusite wrote .... The Personal Georaphy one was disappointing since it was written with a cowtown mentality, which is a shame as the author is a professor from OSU....
I'm curious why you say "cowtown mentality" -- I rather enjoyed this book, one of the first histories of Columbus I've read. It's admittedly personal -- but he puts that right in the title. I like that he starts, literally, with the geography of Columbus. I've always been mystified why so much industry seems ot be upwind of the city. I admit, my attention started to wane in the closing chapters, when plucky preservationists launch battle after battle to save landmarks you know are now just surface parking lots.
I like the Arcadia postcard books as a snapshot of the city, but the history in them can be sketchy. (Not just in the Columbus books; I've heard that complaint about the Cincinnati series and others as well.) Meh. I like the pictures anyway.
I enjoyed A Fragile Capitol as well. It was really a great overview of the early days of Columbus. (Commerical transporation on the Scioto -- who knew?) And I highly recommend Nick Taggert's photo history of Columbus, not just because he used ot be my neighbor!
I really liked the Magnuson book, too -- altho' maybe 'enjoyed' is not the right word -- it's pretty bleak! I didn't realize it was set in South Linden. When it first came out, I was living in Short North/VV. The prostitutes were still turning tricks in the alley behind my place, and there was that seedy little strip right around the corner on High St. with Swan's Cleaners, the sign place, and a rental store right. I thought that was Winky's place...
Sitting on my desk right now is Built to Move Millions: Streetcar Building in Ohio, about the development and demise of the lines. Somehow I don't think it's going to be one of my all time favs, but it's worth a read.
When I first moved here in 1991, I was surprised so few people seemed to know (or care) anything about the city's history. I also didn't like the city. But I found the more I read about the history of the city, not just the Woody Hayes/OSU hoopla, the more I like Columbus.