December 7, 2012 5:29 am at 5:29 am #94929
Darren G.ParticipantLogin to Send PM
The “HUB” Stadium smART Complex…
The next evolution of the museum experience.
Combines the refined ambience of an art museum, the intellectual stimulation of a contemporary art center, the functionality of a library, the utility of a university and the convenience of a mall into one “Superchapel of Creativity,” one Creative Class “HUB.”
Involves the synthetic integration of Columbus, Ohio’s three main cultural arts institutions, namely…
The Columbus Museum of Art,
The Ohio State University’s Wexner Center for the Arts, and
The Columbus Downtown Metropolitan Library
…into one art mall-like smART Complex
• Other “HUB” assets include a MLK Wing (to make accommodations for various ethnic galleries), the “Great Hall” Lecture Pavilion (run by a university cooperative comprised of participating local colleges) and an indoor/outdoor concert venue for local musicians, if desired.
• Subsidiary Establishment beneficiaries include the OSU Department of Art, Columbus College of Art and Design, Ohio Historical Society, Ohioana, Columbus Cultural Arts Center, Daughters of the Revolution and Experience Columbus.
The aggregate result of the “HUB” design synthesis is a win-win innovation in institutional dynamics that requires a mixed-use cooperative business model between government, semi-private and semi-public organizations.
Reasons for this recalibration involve emergent factors in evolutionary dynamics, non-zero-sum game theory and the reconstitution of the Commons.
Thesis Statement: The new organizational model created by a synthetic integration of the Columbus Museum of Art, OSU Wexner Center for the Arts and Columbus Metropolitan Library into one “HUB” facility represents a new Integral paradigm in institutional aesthetics.
Definition of terms, ideas and applied contexts (words identified by underlines)…
Thesis/Thesis Statement: According to Wikipedia… “A thesis statement, in essays, is a line which clarifies the main argument for the rest of the essay. The thesis statement is usually found at the end of the first paragraph of an essay or similar document and summarizes the main point and perspective of the writer. The main function of a thesis statement is to introduce the reader to the purpose of the document and outline the major topics that will be covered to achieve that purpose”; whereas a “thesis is an intellectual proposition.”
• The thesis to support the development of the “HUB” Stadium smART Complex represents a complexity theory; the complexity theory in turn symbolizes as a philosophy; with the philosophy in turn being self-defined as an emergent phenomenon within the context of control theory. Combined, the “HUB” proposal establishes a biomatrix systems theory upon which to build a new “Renaissance Revival” cultural paradigm for Columbus, Ohio.
Proposition: According to Wikipedia… “In philosophy and logic, the term proposition refers to either (a) the ‘content’ or ‘meaning’ of a meaningful declarative sentence or (b) the pattern of symbols, marks, or sounds that make up a meaningful declarative sentence. The meaning of a proposition includes having the quality or property of being either true or false, and as such propositions are claimed to be truthbearers.”
• The various propositions of truth being discussed in this thesis are whether or not the aggregate benefits of the “HUB” Stadium smART Complex would be a significant enough improvement to the cultural image of the city to brand it nationally as a Creative Class hub; whether or not the aggregate benefits of the “HUB” Stadium smART Complex would dramatically increase the cultural value of those participating institutions whose individual benefits are currently limited by their isolation from one another, their segregation a reflection of a Reductionism development model; whether or not the “HUB” aggregate model represents a new evolutionary institutional paradigm; whether or not there is a present or future cultural need or demand fulfilled by the creation of a “HUB” Stadium smART Complex; whether or not the negation of the “HUB” will have a negative affect on the cultural reputation of Columbus as a Creative Class hub; and whether or not the “HUB” development represents a Commons-based tipping point phenomenon.
Philosophies: According to Wikipedia… “Philosophies: particular schools of thought, styles of philosophy, or descriptions of philosophical ideas attributed to a particular group or culture.”
• The “HUB” concept museum is a home-grown idea, a Columbus original. It is an innovation towards a new cultural development model that ranks right up there with other Columbus-based aggregate development milestones, including the first strip mall (Town and Country), the first grocery store (Big Bear) and the first department store (Lazarus). The “HUB” concept museum merely applies the governing dynamic principle that has become one of the standard business models and incorporates it into a cooperative institutional model. “The “HUB” thus represents a continuation of a cultural legacy and is part and parcel of an overarching Columbus-based philosophy.
Commons: According to Wikipedia… “Commons refers to the cultural and natural resources accessible to all members of a society, including natural materials such as air, water, and a habitable earth. These resources are held in common, not owned privately. The resources held in common can include everything from natural resources and common land to software. The commons contains public property and private property, over which people have certain traditional rights. When commonly held property is transformed into private property this process alternatively is termed ‘enclosure’ or more commonly, ‘privatization.’ A person who has a right in, or over, common land jointly with another or others is called a commoner.” (Italics mine).
• Given that each of the three major cultural institutions synthesized within the “HUB” design share a similar mission to serve the public and promote the public welfare through art and education-based cultural activities, and given that the Columbus Museum of Art, OSU’s Wexner Center for the Arts and Columbus Downtown Metropolitan Library are as cultural icons symbols of the community in general, the view that these institutions are integral components of the cultural commons is an undeniable fact. These institutions represent Columbus’ cultural Establishment; the Establishment represents the face of the People (i.e., the commoner or so-called “everyman”). To the extent that the identity of the commoner is dependent upon these major cultural institutions for its cultural identity, we can establish with absolute logical certainty that these institutions belong to the commons.
• Being representations of the commons, these institutions are required to be responsive to the needs of the commoners; and likewise, as commoners, we have an obligation to take collective responsibility over the stewardship of the commons. For this reason, if a better institutional model can be developed that better serves the needs of the commoner on a holistic or collective basis, then it is the implicit right of the commoner to affect commons-based change. The evaluative basis for judging the merits of any commons-based improvement will be the aggregate benefits derived from its implementation and the resultant increased utility of the commons by the commoners, the increased utility thus constituting a fundamental expansion of the commons in practical terms; which in this case means either (a) more people visiting the “HUB” than the sum of the people currently visiting the Columbus Museum of Art, Wexner Center for the Arts and Columbus Metropolitan Library combined, or (b) the same number of people experience the benefits of what the “HUB” has to offer as the sum of the people visiting the Columbus Museum of Art, Wexner Center for the Arts and Columbus Metropolitan Library, but because each visitor has the potential to experience the synthesized benefits of each in combination at the “HUB,” the benefit each “HUB” visitor experiences in threefold what could have been achieved by a visit to either of the segregated institutions in isolation.
Aggregate: According to Wikipedia… “An aggregate is a collection of items that are gathered together to form a total quantity.”
• The bringing together of the Columbus Museum of Art, OSU Wexner Center for the Arts and Columbus Metropolitan Library into one “HUB” smART Complex is a design aggregate that creates a corollary set of aggregate benefits. These aggregate benefits in turn represent a gestalt.
Gestalt: According to Wikipedia… “Gestalt psychology or gestaltism (German: Gestalt – ‘essence or shape of an entity’s complete form’) is a theory of mind and brain of the Berlin School; the operational principle of gestalt psychology is that the brain is holistic, parallel, and analog, with self-organizing tendencies. The principle maintains that… the whole is greater than the sum of its parts.” (Italics mine).
• The self-organizing principle behind the “HUB” is the analog and parallel characteristics found in the cultural arts institutions involved. In other words, because the arts and humanities is the shared trait found in each of the “HUB’s” participating organizations, that common thread becomes the basis by which to bind them together into a cooperative business alignment. The unity thus created is holistic in nature, while the evolution of its synthetic integration establishes the model for a new design paradigm.
• A similar concept to the gestalt idea that “the whole is greater than the sum of its parts” is the win-win principle of non-zero-sum game found in Game Theory.
Game Theory: According to Wikipedia… “game theory is a study of strategic decision making. More formally, it is ‘the study of mathematical models of conflict and cooperation between intelligent rational decision-makers.’”
• Unfortunately, the point at which “rational decision-makers” is required is where the “HUB” strategy breaks down. Luckily, because the “HUB” is a commons development issue, if enough commoners get involved – become self-organized – a critical mass of support can grow to fill the leadership void. At which point the commoners become the managing decision-makers in the development of the commons. Such a movement would have historic repercussions. It would also attract the attention of the nation and give the city the opportunity it needs to stake its claim as an emergent Creative Class hub.
To be continued…December 7, 2012 12:34 pm at 12:34 pm #522495
dermParticipantLogin to Send PM
I like your energy in your recent posts. I am a museum and art fan and like how our city is growing that way. The above post seems to describe the Wex in about an 80 percent accurate picture, have you had a chance to fully explore it? The current photo exhibit is pretty big stuff. It does music, national stuff, art shows, university integrated, creative. What does the Wex lack you are looking for?
While the Wex is lacking a library component, I am not sure that it is feasible to add this to your hub idea. Did you know Columbus is already one of the top cities in the United States for Libraries? One thing to note is the recent pact between the Columbus Metro and the Grandview library and its affiliates to integrate all their collections electronically. This adds together two of the top libraries in the US to increase searchable titles into the hundreds of thousands. It is a major positive for central Ohio that I am not sure people are aware of. We do not lack a Library scene in Columbus.
Also the OSU library is a short walk across the oval from the Wex.December 7, 2012 1:42 pm at 1:42 pm #522496
Sure is a lot of information. I would think I would have tried to find a more stable source than Wikipedia for my Thesis.December 7, 2012 2:15 pm at 2:15 pm #522497
groundrulesParticipantLogin to Send PM
dood is trying so hard to sound smart.December 7, 2012 2:23 pm at 2:23 pm #522498
and flood the message boards with his vision.December 7, 2012 2:38 pm at 2:38 pm #522499
Dude needs to find some backers, buy a warehouse and make it happen.December 7, 2012 2:40 pm at 2:40 pm #522500
Dude needs to find some backers, buy a warehouse and make it happen.
maybe gil ligg will back him?December 7, 2012 2:47 pm at 2:47 pm #522501
maybe gil ligg will back him?
Inner core can be the developer. It can be a millenial creative class über circle jerk.December 7, 2012 2:58 pm at 2:58 pm #522502
SnarfParticipantLogin to Send PM
and flood the message boards with his vision.
We needed another hub thread like we need another bicyclist thread.December 7, 2012 3:02 pm at 3:02 pm #522503
We needed another hub thread like we need another bicyclist thread.
I’m waiting for spring ;)December 7, 2012 3:03 pm at 3:03 pm #522504
We needed another hub thread like we need another bicyclist thread.
so when are we getting light rail?December 7, 2012 3:09 pm at 3:09 pm #522505
rusParticipantLogin to Send PM
so when are we getting light rail?
Will it be located near some locally produced bacon?December 7, 2012 3:13 pm at 3:13 pm #522506
Will it be located near some locally produced bacon?
only if that bacon is nationally ranked on forbes.December 7, 2012 3:16 pm at 3:16 pm #522507
But, have you tried the pizza?December 7, 2012 3:21 pm at 3:21 pm #522508
ricospazParticipantLogin to Send PM
What is the ratio of bacon to art to pizza to light rail?
- Restaurant Reviews
- New Restaurants
- Food Trucks
- Beer, Wine & Spirits
- Treats to Try
- Coffee Addiction
- A Kitchen Inspired
- RSS Feed
Best Bites: Burgers Returns to The Brewery District on April 23rd
Last fall, Columbus Underground hosted its first ever "Best Bites" event — a new…
Barley’s Expansion Would Triple Brewing Capacity
Earlier this week, we learned that Barley's Brewing Company has plans to relocate their…
Little Eater to Operate New Grocery Business at North Market
Ever since the Greener Grocer closed up shop at the end of 2014, the…
Merion Village Furniture Shop Launches Art Gallery
T.Y. Fine Furniture has called Merion Village home since last August when owner Tarik…
Orange Barrel Media Pays Homage to Franklinton History With New Mural
On Friday, Franklinton took one step closer to becoming the city's official new arts…
GCAC Presents: The Making of a Band: Capital Pride Band Celebrating 10 Years
In 1999, a lone trumpet player showed up on a dare at the Bat-N-Rouge…
Plan for North Broadway Development Presented to Neighborhood
Representatives of Northstar Realty presented details of their proposed five-story, mixed-use development at the…
Lifestyle Communities Interested in More RiverSouth Development
Last week it was revealed that the two-building LC RiverSouth development Downtown would be…
- Columbus Politics
- Franklin County Politics
- Ohio Politics
- National Politics
- Upcoming Civic Meetings
- RSS Feed
Besa Sharrah Campaigns for City Council With a ‘Triangle’ of Issues
Besa Sharrah is one of four endorsed Republicans in this year’s City Council campaign,…
Kiwan Lawson Pushes Accountability in City Council Campaign
It was while Columbus native Kiwan Lawson was attending Marion-Franklin High School that he…
- Mega Weekend
- Parks & Recreation
- RSS Feed
Yoga At The Yard Opens in Grandview
“Here comes the sun!” says Alyson Sullivan, owner of Yoga At The Yard in…
Photos: The Capital Pride Band 10th Anniversary Concert
The Capital Pride Band of Columbus celebrated 10 years of music this past weekend…