Development| Published on August 16, 2007 1:32 pm

Firestone Mansion on Broad Street to be demolished

By: Motorist


The Columbus Foundation owns this building on Broad Street and are planning on demolishing it and from what I understand, plant gardens there. It’s a little disappointing that a institution that does so much good would do something so wasteful and, in my opinion, disrespectful. They are building a new building behind the old governors mansion that is going to be LEED certified. You would think that if they were truly interested in sustainability, they would find a way to reuse this structure instead of destroying it. I was told that this used to be home to the Firestone family. It is right next to the Broadwin and across from a block of houses that were slated to be demolished in the 90′s. Casto ended up buying those and saving them and now they are some of the most beautiful homes in the neighborhood.

Word through the grapevine is that the President of the Olde Towne East Neighborhood Association has tried to contact them many times but has not gotten any sort of response. Today a coworker told me that there is now a construction fence around the building and construction equipment sitting next to it.

We lost an equally impressive mansion on Broad Street a few years ago. The church that owned it decided to tear it down and replace it with a gravel parking lot.

I don’t really know if anything can be done to prevent this. None of the papers had much in them about this. We just found out about this in the neighborhood a couple weeks ago so I’m guessing they tried to keep it hushed up until it was too late to do anything about. Sucks.

Here’s their press release:

[url]http://www.columbusfoundation.org/GD/Templates/Pages/TCF/TCFSecondary.aspx?page=470[/url]

60 Comments

  • Maybe instead of a garden they should install a roller-coaster.

  • No, that would go down the middle of Broad Street. Take Broad back to a boulevard and use the planting areas to put rollercoaster supports. Unfortunately, I don’t think the alleys on either side of Broad Street are continuous enough to put it there.

  • Seems like a real waste. I would be OK with them tearing down the building right next to the firestone mansion (the 60s, 70′s looking office building) but the firestone is really a landmark. I hope I can get inside to take some pics before they tear it down. Seems that the Columbus Foundation should have enough ideas on the importance of Historic Preservation not to do this, but they do many stupid things- like pay for me to go to college, fat chance that was a very good investment!

    What if we start a movement to get it on the National Register of Historic Places? That may impede their plans a bit- Don’t think you are allowed to tear down structures on the national register.

    Broad Steet, Columbus

    East Broad back in the day

  • A roller coaster down the middle of Broad Street would both attract and retain me.

  • Is this for sure or just speculation?

  • I called Columbus Foundation today. The receptionist confirmed that they are tearing it down. She took my name and number down and said someone will call me to talk more about it. We’ll see if that actually happens.

    A roller coaster down the middle of Broad Street would both attract and retain me.

    That’s what I’m talkin about.

  • At least they aren’t planning a parking lot.

  • i’m pretty sure this plan has been in the works for quite some time. i actually worked in the carriage house behind the governor’s mansion (up until a month and a half ago). they’re making changes and doing renovations all over the place.

  • I don’t doubt that they’ve been working on it for some time; it would take at least a year or two to plan something like this renovation/expansion. I’ve lived in OTE for over 4 years. For almost 3 of that, I’ve lived about 3 blocks from this house. This is the first I’ve ever heard of this, same with many of my neighbors. One person told me that they brought it up once a few years ago but then they never heard of it again. At the time, it was made known to them that nobody wants to see it go. I’m sure they are well aware how sensitive us OTE residents are to demolition and know that there would be a shitstorm if word got out about this too soon.

    As for the parking lot, I’m not sure what they have planned and where. From the little bit in the press release, it sounds like they are building where the parking lot is currently. If they do that, they’ll have to have a new parking lot somewhere.

    In between this house and the Broadwin is a wasteland that used to be a gas station. It will be nice to see that corner cleaned up. I just find it a bit hard to believe that with all the resources at their disposal, Columbus Foundation couldn’t find a way to preserve this one.

  • When you see the picture above it only makes you feel sadness for what used to be.

  • I wonder if there is a way to block them from getting LEED certification?

  • I did get a call from Doug Kridler of the Columbus Foundation yesterday. Take this for what it’s worth, but he said that they have had architects and engineers look at the building and nobody could come up with a way to make the building work for what they need. He also mentioned that they are spending 8 million on the renovation and expansion and that it would have been much cheaper to move into an office building downtown but they want to stay in the neighborhood. And a section of the roof recently fell in and thieves have broken into it for the copper and probably whatever else they could drag out of there.

    He emailed me a copy of the site plan for the project but it is a PDF. If someone knows how to post that on here, I can try that. Or I can email it to anyone interested in seeing it.

  • If you send it to me I will post it online and make a linky.

    mlreed328 at gmail.com

  • That sucks. Ive seen that place many times and thought it had alot of potential

  • Yes this really does suck. I grew up in C-bus and I have seen so much change, all these old buildings torn down because nobody knows what to do with them.

    Sure change is inevitable, but when we get rid of the old classics we erase a little more of our history.

    well, if it’s too expensive & nobody wants it , what can you do?

    :P

  • I went to douglas elementary right down the street from there and can remember that building standing out ever since.

  • Forgot to mention, Columbus Landmarks Foundation and Olde Towne East Neighborhood Association are meeting with Columbus Foundation this afternoon to discuss this. We’ll see what, if anything, comes out of that meeting.

  • There’s a big vacant gravel lot right next to this mansion. Idiots. And when is the city stepping in?

  • There’s a group called the Columbus Landmarks Foundation, but they tend to be silent when significant buildings are at risk. Especially if those buildings are owned by, say, Children’s Hospital, the City, or Columbus Foundation.

    If they aren’t going to be a leader in preservation, maybe they should disband.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.